c:o/re Fellow 11/26 – 09/27

© Heike Lachmann

Cyrus Mody has been Professor of the History of Science, Technology, and Innovation at Maastricht University since 2015. Before that, he taught at Rice University in Houston from 2007 to 2015, and was a fellow and staff member at the Chemical Heritage Foundation (now the Science History Institute) from 2004 to 2007. Mody has published three monographs with MIT Press on the recent history of the US physical and engineering sciences and university-industry-government cooperation, especially in fields related to the semiconductor industry. He is active on several editorial boards and was editor of Engineering Studies, 2018-2022.

From 2020 to 2026 Mody was PI of the Dutch Research Council project Managing Scarcity, which explored the oil industry’s involvement with alternative energy and environmental governance; and since 2021 a co-PI of the European Research Council Synergy project NanoBubbles, which asks “how, when, and why scientists fail to correct the scientific record.”


Un/critical Varieties of Science

Thomas Kuhn famously described the “essential tension” between “normal science,” guided by established rules and knowledge, and “revolutionary science” that questions core methods and beliefs. Although the public rhetoric of science – and influential philosophical and legal understandings of science – prizes Popperian permanent revolution, in fact science would be impossible if all prior beliefs were interrogated all the time – normal science is normal and necessary.

Thus, both critical and less-than-critical varieties of science are integral to the scientific enterprise. Yet we can distinguish other varieties of science by their relationship to critique – varieties that are less necessary and pose significant epistemological risks. Normal science’s lack of ambition, for instance, can give way to sloppy science; and its reluctance to question prior knowledge can allow erroneous science to persist (or even to become zombie science impervious to critique). Normal science’s acceptance of the rules of the game can encourage fraudulent science that cheats those rules via paper mills, citation rings, authorship fraud, invented/manipulated data, and so on.

Similarly, revolutionary science is critical of established belief yet mostly uncritical of its own assumptions. Since Kuhn’s time (and partly inspired by him) whole fields have arisen that consist entirely of critique yet often fail at reflexive self-examination: Science and Technology studies (STS), Science of Science (SciSci or SoS), Metascience, etc. More worryingly, organized, well-funded science denialism campaigns – anti-vax, climate denial, race “realism,” gender “critical” theory, etc. – have appropriated the language of critique (and sometimes the ideas, tools, and even personnel of STS) to advance faux-critical science.

This project explores un/critical varieties of science through (mainly historical) case studies of STS, scientific “bubbles,” fraudulent critique (climate denial), and fraud-as-critique. The aim is to understand how critique and its others interrelate and to encourage healthier, more reflective forms of critique.

Publications (selection)

Mody, Cyrus C. M. (2025). Taking the Marks to the Market: The Oil Industry and the Entrepreneurial Turn. In M. D. Gordin and W. P. McCray (Eds.), Greedy Science: Creating Knowledge, Making Money, and Being Famous in the 1980s. Johns Hopkins University Press.

Mody, Cyrus C. M. (2024). Maurice Strong, Conspiracy Theories, and the Pitfalls of Environmental Diplomacy. NiCHE blog (May 21, 2024): https://niche-canada.org/2024/05/21/maurice-strong-conspiracy-theories-and-the-pitfalls-of-environmental-diplomacy/.

Mody, Cyrus C. M. (2022). The Squares: US Physical and Engineering Scientists in the Long 1970s. MIT Press.

Mody, Cyrus C. M., Sibum, H. Otto and Roberts, Lissa L. (2020). Integrating Research Integrity into the History of Science. History of Science, 58(4), 369-385.

Mody, Cyrus C. M. (2017). The Long Arm of Moore’s Law: Microelectronics and American Science. MIT Press.